top of page

Navigating Conflicting Hitting Theories in Baseball Coaching

When it comes to baseball coaching, there are a variety of opinions and theories on how to hit the ball effectively. As a result, it's not uncommon for coaches to have opposing ideas or for different coaches to give conflicting advice. Here are a few answers to some questions that may arise when discussing this topic:

1. Why do some coaches have opposing ideas and opposite theories?

  • One of the reasons coaches may have opposing ideas is simply because they have different experiences and backgrounds in the sport. For example, one coach may have played at a high level and developed their own hitting philosophy based on their personal experiences, while another coach may have developed their approach through extensive research and study. Additionally, coaches may have different philosophies based on the strengths and weaknesses of the players they work with.

2. Why do some coaches say keep your front shoulder closed, while others say opening it up and rotating through the ball?

  • Coaches may have different approaches based on the player's physical attributes and swing mechanics. For instance, a coach may suggest keeping the front shoulder closed for a hitter who tends to open up too early in their swing, causing them to lose power and direction. Alternatively, a coach may suggest opening up the front shoulder and rotating through the ball for a hitter who struggles to generate enough bat speed or who tends to pull off the ball. Ultimately, the goal is to help the hitter find a swing that works for them and maximizes their abilities.

3. Isn't there one way to hit the baseball?

  • No, there isn't one way to hit the baseball. Baseball is a complex sport that involves a variety of skills and strategies. What works for one player may not work for another. Additionally, hitting is a highly individualized skill that requires a unique approach for each player. As a result, coaches may need to tailor their advice and approach to fit the individual needs of each hitter. However, there are some basic principles that apply to hitting, such as proper mechanics, balance, and timing, which can serve as a foundation for any hitting philosophy.

In conclusion, coaches may have different theories and approaches when it comes to hitting, but ultimately, their goal is to help each player maximize their potential at the plate. By understanding the individual needs of each hitter, coaches can provide tailored advice and guidance to help them develop an effective swing that works for them. While there isn't one definitive way to hit a baseball, by focusing on fundamentals and working with each player's unique strengths and weaknesses, coaches can help their players become successful hitters.


bottom of page